The Impact of Family Dynamics on Wills Variation Claims

Wills Variation | October 14, 2023 | Written by Natasha Nair

Wills variation claims allow certain eligible family members to challenge the allocation of a deceased individual’s estate because it does not adequately provide for their needs or expectations. The outcome of such claims can be significantly influenced by the intricate web of family dynamics, which play a pivotal role in the evaluation process. As experts in family law, the team from Linley Welwood has seen first-hand the significant impact that family dynamics can have on wills variation claims. That is why our experts have compiled some information on the impact of family dynamics on wills variation claims.

Learn about wills variation in BC.

Family Conflicts and Estrangement

Family dynamics characterized by conflicts, estrangement, or strained relationships can profoundly impact wills variation claims. The court implicitly considers whether such dynamics were instrumental in the deceased’s decision regarding estate distribution. Evidence of strained relationships can bolster the claimant’s case, suggesting personal biases or animosities may have influenced the deceased.

Expectations and Promises

Expectations and promises within families further complicate the matter. These promises create strong expectations when someone is assured about inheriting certain assets or being provided for financially; however, when these expectations are not met in the final will, it often leads to disappointment and resentment among family members. Such broken promises fuel disputes and act as ammunition for those wanting to challenge the validity of a will.

Financial Needs and Dependence

Financial needs and dependence add another layer of complexity to these cases. When certain family members financially depend on the deceased’s assets, they often argue that they should be entitled to a more significant portion of the estate to meet their ongoing obligations. This argument can lead to heated debates about what constitutes fair provision and who deserves more support.

Moral Obligations and Cultural Norms

Cultural norms and moral obligations are crucial in shaping family dynamics, affecting wills variation claims. Some cultures prioritize equitable asset distribution among family members, while others emphasize caring for specific relatives, such as parents or siblings. The court implicitly acknowledges these cultural and moral dimensions when assessing the fairness of the provisions in the will.

Independent Legal Advice

Seeking independent legal advice is crucial when dealing with wills variation claims, as it helps individuals navigate the intricacies of estate law while considering their unique family dynamics. An experienced lawyer can provide valuable insights into the validity of a claim and assess whether there are moral or legal grounds for challenging or defending against it. Independent legal advice helps all parties understand their rights, responsibilities, and options.

Evidence and Documentation

The evidence presented in these claims often hinges on personal interactions, conversations, and unwritten understandings influenced by family dynamics. Gathering and presenting strong evidence is critical. Such evidence may include letters, emails, witness testimonies, or other documentation that supports the claimant’s arguments regarding the deceased’s intentions, relationships, and obligations.

Feel free to contact the knowledgeable team at Linley Welwood to expand your knowledge on will variation claims. Our experts are just a click away. Fill out our online contact form, and we will be more than happy to assist you with any questions or concerns regarding our services.

We give you the personal attention you deserve.Schedule a Consult

Schedule a consultation.

    Please fill in all required fields as indicated with a red star.